DWC Root Rot Fix: Complete Prevention and Treatment Guide healthy white roots vs brown pythium root rot dwc
| |

DWC Root Rot Fix: Complete Prevention and Treatment Guide

Home

Hydroponics

DWC Root Rot Fix: Complete Prevention and Treatment Guide
Last Reviewed: August 2026  | 
Author: Faisal Habib  | 
Fact-Checked: Lab and Field Verified  | 
Expert Reviewer: Wara Danish, MSc Plant Biology
Difficulty: Intermediate
| Treatment Time: 48–72 Hours | Estimated Flush Cost: $5 to $15 | Target Safe Temp: 65°F–68°F
Quick Answer: The Definitive DWC Root Rot Fix

To execute an immediate dwc root rot fix, isolate the system, prune away blackened root slime, and run a 3-day sterile flush using 34% hydrogen peroxide at 1 mL/gal (or 3% H2O2 at 10 mL/gal) in pure pH 5.8 water with maximum aeration. Prevent recurrence by locking water temperatures between 65°F and 68°F (18°C–20°C), delivering ≥ 8.5 mg/L dissolved oxygen with fine-pore air stones, and inoculating fresh solution with Bacillus amyloliquefaciens. Calculate system dosages with our Reservoir Size Calculator.

📖 Definition: Hydroponic Root Rot (Pythium Ultimum)

An aggressive water mold (oomycete) infection that colonizes subterranean root tissue under hypoxic (dissolved oxygen <5.0 mg/L) and elevated thermal (>72°F) conditions. Pathogenic zoospores enzymatically degrade outer root cortical cells, producing a distinctive brown mucilage, sloughing root sheaths, and sulfur-like anaerobic gas emissions that block water and mineral translocation.

📜 Table of Contents — Click to Expand
⚠️ What Most Beginner Guides Miss

  • The Chemical Neutralization Fallacy: Combining hydrogen peroxide and beneficial bacteria simultaneously destroys both; peroxide oxidizes beneficial bacteria on contact, leaving dead organic sludge that feeds future Pythium blooms.
  • Nutrient Staining vs. Active Pathology: Dark organic fertilizers (humic acids, kelp) stain roots dark tan but leave root hairs firm and odorless; killing stained roots with peroxide flushes destroys healthy micro-hairs needlessly.
  • Henry’s Law Oxygen Inversion: Water at 76°F holds 22% less dissolved oxygen than water at 65°F, while root metabolic respiration demands double, causing an acute oxygen deficit that triggers zoospore attack.
  • Air Stone Biofilm Sequestration: Porous ceramic air diffusers harbor Pythium spores inside micro-pores that bleach cannot penetrate; air stones must be replaced, not cleaned, following an infection.
  • Sub-Canopy Transpiration Lag: Above-ground leaves remain green for 3 to 5 days after root vascular channels collapse; diagnosing root health via leaf inspection is always too late.
Side-by-side comparison of healthy white hydroponic roots versus brown slime-coated Pythium root rot
Figure 1: Morphological comparison: Healthy oxygenated DWC roots with white lateral branching (left) versus necrotic, slime-coated Pythium infection (right). Photo: CurrentGardening Lab.

1. Diagnosing Root Rot vs. Benign Organic Nutrient Staining

Accurately implementing a dwc root rot fix requires distinguishing between true water mold infections and harmless nutrient staining. Dark organic additives—such as concentrated humic acids, fulvic acids, and cold-water kelp extracts—naturally dye healthy white root hairs tan or light brown.

The Tactile Pull Test: Take a small cluster of discolored roots between your thumb and forefinger and gently slide downward. Healthy, nutrient-stained roots feel firm, springy, and resist tensile pull. Pythium-infected roots are covered in slippery gelatinous mucilage; the outer root cortex will slide off like a wet sleeve, exposing a thin, stringy inner vascular stele.

The Olfactory Test: A healthy hydroponic root zone smells neutral, clean, and earthy, resembling fresh spring rain. Pythium and anaerobic bacteria emit a sharp, offensive odor resembling rotting cabbage, stagnant pond muck, or hydrogen sulfide (sewer gas).

Close-up of dark brown slime-coated hydroponic roots showing severe Pythium root rot damage
Figure 2: Advanced cortical sloughing in DWC roots, demonstrating complete structural breakdown of root hairs from Pythium colonization. Photo: CurrentGardening Lab.

2. The Etiology of Infection: Temperature, Oxygen Depletion & Zoospore Kinetics

Pythium and Phytophthora are opportunistic oomycetes present in low background concentrations in almost all municipal water sources and indoor air. In a well-aerated, cool hydroponic reservoir, these organisms remain completely dormant as inactive oospores.

Infection is triggered by root zone hypoxia (dissolved oxygen dropping below 5.0 mg/L). When water temperatures climb above 72°F (22°C), physical gas solubility drops while root metabolic respiration rates double. Stressed, oxygen-starved roots experience cellular lysis, leaking amino acids and carbohydrates into the water.

These root exudates trigger the chemical activation of biflagellate Pythium zoospores. Zoospores swim chemotactically toward the elongation zone of root tips, encysting on cell walls and secreting cellulase and pectinase enzymes that dissolve root tissue within hours.

3. Sterile Chemical Oxidation vs. Beneficial Biological Defense Matrix

Managing root health in Deep Water Culture requires choosing between two mutually exclusive operational paths: The Sterile Approach (continuous chemical oxidation) or The Biological Approach (rhizosphere colonization). Combining them is chemically destructive.

Comparison of Hydroponic Root Zone Hygiene Protocols
Operational Parameter Sterile Regimen (Oxidizing) Biological Regimen (Living Shield)
Primary Chemical / Agent 34% Hydrogen Peroxide (H2O2) or Hypochlorous Acid (HOCl) Bacillus amyloliquefaciens & Trichoderma harzianum
Mechanism of Eradication Rapidly oxidizes and lyses all organic cellular membranes on contact. Colonizes root hairs, physically blocking Pythium attachment sites.
Speed of Response Immediate (active oxidation within 60 seconds). Preventative (requires 48–72 hours for bacterial colonization).
Water Temperature Tolerance High: Prevents rot in warm water up to 75°F (24°C). Strict: Biological activity degrades above 72°F (22°C).
Application Best Use Emergency Treatment: Eradicating active, visible slime outbreaks. Long-Term Prevention: Maintaining clean, uninfected reservoirs.
🏆 Agronomic Rule Execute a sterile peroxide flush to eliminate active pathogens, run clean water for 48 hours, then switch permanently to a beneficial biological inoculant for ongoing crop defense.

4. Step-by-Step Emergency Hydrogen Peroxide Flush Protocol

  1. 1

    Isolate and Drain the Infected Reservoir

    Immediately disconnect the infected bucket or reservoir from any recirculating loop. Pump out and discard 100% of the diseased nutrient solution into a sanitary drain; never reuse contaminated water.

  2. 2

    Mechanical Root Debridement and Sanitize Hardware

    Lift the plant and gently rinse root slime with cool water. Use sterilized shears to prune away severely blackened, mushy root filaments that detach easily. Scrub the empty reservoir bucket and airline with a 10% bleach solution and rinse clean.

  3. 3

    Fill Reservoir with pH-Balanced Water and Dose Peroxide

    Refill the reservoir with pure water adjusted to pH 5.8 without adding fertilizer salts. Dose 34% technical-grade hydrogen peroxide at 1.0 mL per gallon (or standard 3% H2O2 at 10.0 mL per gallon) and mix thoroughly.

  4. 4

    Run Sterile Oxygenated Oxidation Cycle for 48 to 72 Hours

    Submerge the root mass and run continuous maximum aeration. Active bubbling will occur as peroxide oxidizes pathogen cells. Maintain this sterile bath for 48 to 72 hours until root bubbling ceases and slime dissolves.

  5. 5

    Drain, Recharge Nutrients, and Inoculate with Beneficial Microbes

    Drain the spent peroxide water. Refill with fresh nutrient solution at half-strength vegetative EC (1.0–1.2 mS/cm) at 66°F. Inoculate with Bacillus amyloliquefaciens to establish a protective biological root shield.

Infographic summarizing the 5-step emergency hydrogen peroxide root rot flush protocol for DWC hydroponics
Figure 3: Infographic protocol: 5-step emergency hydrogen peroxide flush and beneficial bacterial inoculation timeline. Photo: CurrentGardening Lab.

5. Water Chiller Thermodynamics & Dissolved Oxygen Henry’s Law Table

The physical solubility of dissolved oxygen in water is governed by Henry’s Law: oxygen saturation is inversely proportional to solution temperature. Operating reservoirs above 70°F creates a severe physiological bottleneck where oxygen solubility drops while root respiration demand spikes.

Water Chiller Sizing & Dissolved Oxygen Saturation by Temperature
Water Temperature Max DO Saturation (mg/L) Pythium Activity Level Chiller HP (20–40 Gal) Agronomic Status
60°F – 64°F (15.5°C–17.7°C) 9.8 – 9.4 mg/L Completely Dormant 1/4 HP Chiller High DO; slightly slowed phosphorus uptake.
65°F – 68°F (18.3°C–20.0°C) 9.2 – 8.8 mg/L Suppressed 1/10 to 1/4 HP Chiller THE GOLDILOCKS ZONE: Peak growth, zero rot risk.
72°F – 74°F (22.2°C–23.3°C) 8.4 – 8.1 mg/L Active Germination Undersized / Inactive DANGER: Zoospores infect stressed root tips.
76°F – 80°F (24.4°C–26.7°C) 7.9 – 7.4 mg/L Explosive Outbreak System Failure LETHAL: Complete root collapse within 72 hours.

6. Deep Sanitization Protocol: Bleach Ratios & Hardware Decontamination

Pythium produces thick-walled sexual oospores that adhere tenaciously to plastic walls, bulkhead fittings, and pump impellers. Rinsing with plain water leaves microscopic biofilms intact, ensuring immediate reinfection of your next crop.

The 10% Chlorine Bleach Decontamination Cycle:

  • 1. System Scrub: Fill the reservoir with warm water and add standard 6% sodium hypochlorite bleach at a ratio of 1/2 cup per gallon (10% concentration). Scrub all bucket walls and lids with a stiff nylon brush.
  • 2. Active Recirculation: Run water pumps and drain manifolds continuously for 4 hours to circulate chlorine through all internal plumbing lines.
  • 3. Complete Dechlorination Rinse: Drain bleach water. Refill with fresh water and dose sodium thiosulfate (chlorine neutralizer) or let the system air-dry completely for 24 hours under ventilation before refilling.
  • 4. Air Stone Replacement: Discard all porous air stones. The internal micro-cavities harbor anaerobic spores that chemical rinses cannot reliably sterilize.

7. Diagnostic Troubleshooting Guide: 10 Verified Root Zone Failure Modes

Use this diagnostic reference table to identify root pathologies, mechanical failures, and chemical imbalances in DWC and hydroponic reservoirs:

Diagnostic Reference for Hydroponic Root Zone Disorders
Observed Symptom Primary Etiology Actionable Corrective Protocol
Dark brown slime coating roots with foul odor Active Pythium water mold infection driven by water >72°F Execute 3-day sterile flush with 34% H2O2 (1 mL/gal); lower water temp to 66°F.
Roots tan/brown but firm, springy, and odorless Benign organic staining from humic acid or kelp additives No treatment required; do not flush with peroxide. Verify DO stays >8.0 mg/L.
Sudden daytime canopy wilting with bubbling water Vascular collapse: root rot has severed water transport Prune dead root sheaths, flush with peroxide, and dim LED lights by 40% to reduce stress.
Green algae forming on net pots and bucket floor Light leaks penetrating through clay pebbles or bucket walls Use opaque black HDPE buckets; top-dress clay pebbles to achieve 100% blackout.
Beneficial bacteria added but roots rot anyway Water temperatures exceeding 74°F or peroxide residue present Install water chiller to lock temp at 66°F; verify zero oxidizers remain in solution.
Stem base turns soft, black, and rots at collar Collar rot from net pot base remaining submerged in water Drop water level to maintain a permanent 1.5 to 2.0-inch air gap below net pot.
Air stone produces large, weak, uneven bubbles Porous micro-pores clogged with Pythium biofilm and salts Discard and replace with a new 4-inch sintered ceramic micro-pore air disc.
Reservoir solution foams white and bubbles violently Peroxide actively oxidizing heavy organic biomass and rot Normal chemical reaction; allow cycle to run for 48 hours until foaming subsides.
Lower mature leaves turn yellow and drop off Nitrogen deficiency caused by decayed roots failing to absorb ions Treat root rot first with peroxide flush before attempting to raise fertilizer EC.
Pathogen returns immediately on next crop cycle Failure to decontaminate plastic surfaces and airlines with bleach Execute full 4-hour 10% chlorine bleach recirculation flush across all plumbing.
💡 Critical Insights Most Growers Overlook

  • Ozone and UV Inline Sterilization: Inline UV-C clarifiers (254nm) kill free-floating zoospores passing through return manifolds without introducing chemical residues into the root zone.
  • Dissolved Oxygen Meter Calibration: Handheld optical DO meters provide immediate early warning of oxygen drops days before visual slime develops.
  • Hypochlorous Acid (HOCl) Maintenance: Dosing 0.5 to 1.0 PPM active free chlorine using food-grade HOCl keeps commercial reservoirs sterile without burning root hairs.
  • Silicon Cell Wall Fortification: Dosing potassium silicate (SiO2 at 50 PPM) hardens root cell walls, creating a physical barrier against fungal enzyme penetration.
🔬 Pro Tip from Faisal Habib

When treating an active root rot outbreak in DWC, reduce your LED grow light intensity by 40% to 50% during the 3-day hydrogen peroxide flush. Damaged root systems cannot support full transpirational water demand under intense lighting. Lowering light intensity reduces canopy moisture stress, preventing fatal midday leaf wilting while the root cortex recovers.

🚫 Common Mistakes to Avoid

  • Mixing peroxide and beneficial bacteria together: Oxidizers destroy living biological colonies instantly, wasting inputs and worsening root rot.
  • Allowing water temperatures to exceed 70°F (21°C): Warm water cannot hold adequate dissolved oxygen, creating an immediate breeding ground for Pythium.
  • Reusing porous air stones after an infection: Contaminated micro-pores harbor pathogen biofilms that re-infect the next planting.
  • Diagnosing root rot by leaf symptoms alone: Above-ground leaves lag behind root destruction by days; inspect roots physically each week.
  • Failing to replace bleach-rinsed water completely: Trace chlorine residues burn delicate new root hairs if not completely neutralized before planting.

Key Takeaways

  • Emergency treatment: Execute a 3-day sterile flush with 34% H2O2 (1 mL/gal) in pure pH 5.8 water to oxidize active root slime and Pythium.
  • Thermal guardrails: Maintain reservoir water strictly between 65°F and 68°F (18°C–20°C) with a mechanical water chiller to preserve dissolved oxygen.
  • Aeration standard: Deliver 1.0 to 1.5 LPM of air per gallon using fine-pore sintered ceramic diffusers to maintain ≥ 8.5 mg/L DO.
  • Protocol separation: Run either a 100% sterile chemical regimen or a 100% biological regimen with Bacillus amyloliquefaciens—never combine them.
  • Next action step: Check your reservoir temperature and size your chiller using our free Reservoir Size Calculator today.
🌿 Get Our Free Hydroponic System Hygiene Blueprints

Join 12,000+ growers receiving weekly science-backed DWC sanitation protocols, chiller sizing charts, and disease prevention schedules.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. Delivered every Tuesday.

Get Free Access Now →

🧮 Calculate Your DWC Reservoir & Chiller Sizing Right Now

Use our free calculator to determine your total water volume, chemical flush dosages, and required water chiller BTU cooling capacity.

Open Free Calculator →

📌 Save This Root Rot Fix Guide to Pinterest

Pin this emergency peroxide flush protocol, chiller sizing chart, and root diagnostic guide to your indoor hydroponics board.

📌 Save to Pinterest

Pinterest pin card for DWC root rot fix showing healthy roots and emergency treatment protocols

8. Frequently Asked Questions

Q1. Why are my roots turning brown but there is no slime?

Firm brown roots without slime or foul odor indicate benign nutrient staining from dark organic additives such as humic acids, fulvic acids, or liquid kelp. Pythium root rot causes roots to become mushy, coated in slippery mucilage, and emit a sulfur swamp odor.

Q2. Will light leaks cause root rot in DWC?

Light leaks do not create Pythium directly, but light entering the reservoir allows green algae to colonize. As algae dies in darkness, decomposing biomass depletes dissolved oxygen and provides a nutrient-rich organic substrate for Pythium zoospores to infect stressed roots.

Q3. Can I use hydrogen peroxide and beneficial bacteria together?

No. Hydrogen peroxide is a non-selective oxidizing agent that instantly lyses beneficial bacteria on contact. You must run a sterile peroxide flush to eradicate an active infection, drain the reservoir, and introduce biological inoculants like Bacillus amyloliquefaciens only after the peroxide has fully dissipated.

Q4. What water temperature kills Pythium spores?

Pythium zoospores survive in dormant states across wide temperature ranges and are not killed by chilling water. Maintaining water temperatures strictly between 65°F and 68°F (18°C–20°C) maximizes dissolved oxygen solubility and suppresses zoospore motility, preventing pathogen colonization.

Q5. How fast can root rot kill a hydroponic plant?

In warm water above 75°F (24°C) with low dissolved oxygen, Pythium can destroy 80% of a plant’s functional root mass within 48 to 72 hours. In shared recirculating systems, zoospores circulate through return manifolds and infect an entire row of plants within 3 days.

Q6. Can I reuse a reservoir after root rot without fully sterilizing it?

No. Pythium forms protective microscopic biofilms on plastic bucket walls, airline tubing, pump impellers, and net pots. All hardware must be scrubbed with a 10% bleach solution, and porous air stones must be replaced to prevent immediate re-infection of subsequent crops.

Q7. Will adding more air stones alone fix an active root rot infection?

Increasing aeration alone will not cure established root rot. Aeration raises dissolved oxygen to prevent future outbreaks, but infected roots covered in bacterial biofilm cannot absorb oxygen. You must chemically oxidize the pathogen with hydrogen peroxide before aeration can restore root function.

FH

Written by Faisal Habib — Hydroponic Systems Specialist

Faisal Habib brings over 12 years of commercial hydroponic engineering experience, specializing in closed-loop DWC sanitation protocols, water chiller integration, and root-zone pathogen eradication in commercial greenhouse facilities globally.
Reviewed by Wara Danish, MSc, Lead Horticultural Agronomist.

📋 Content Update History — Click to View
  • August 2026: Fully upgraded to Gatekeeper V14 specification: Standardized primary keyword to canonical registry (‘dwc root rot fix’, Post ID: 20967), added exact 34% vs 3% H2O2 dilution formulas, Henry’s Law dissolved oxygen saturation table, sterile vs. biological defense matrix, and 10-disorder troubleshooting reference.
  • July 2026: Original publication covering basic peroxide flushes, water temperature benchmarks, and root pull diagnostic tests.
🌱 Complete Hydroponic Health & Maintenance Series

Water Chiller Sizing Guide
Thermodynamic BTU formulas and compressor sizing for indoor hydroponic reservoirs.
Nutrient Lockout Fix Guide
Diagnose salt build-up, pH drift, and flush protocols across all growing media.
Preventing Algae Outbreaks
How to black out reservoirs and eliminate photosynthetic light leaks in DWC systems.
Reservoir Size Calculator
Free tool to calculate water capacity, chemical flush volumes, and chiller BTU demand.

Similar Posts

  • Ideal Grow Tent Humidity & VPD Targets for All Stages

    Home » Hydroponics » Ideal Grow Tent Humidity & VPD Targets for All Stages Last Updated: August 08, 2026 | Reviewed for accuracy, clarity, and safety Quick Answer: The ideal grow tent humidity drops progressively as your plant ages. Seedlings require70% to 80%humidity to establish early roots. Vegetative plants thrive at50% to 70%. Flowering and fruiting plants must be kept strictly between40% to 50%. Dropping the humidity during the flowering stage is absolutely critical to prevent bud rot (Botrytis) and powdery mildew. ⏱️ Time: 30 Minutes 💪 Difficulty: Beginner 💰 Est. Cost: $50 – $150 📋 Table of Contents Seedling Stage: The Dome Environment (70% – 80% RH) Vegetative Stage:…

  • Indoor Plant Lighting Guide: Mastering DLI and Photoperiods

    Home > Gardening Guides > Light Schedule Converter: Find the Right Intensity & Schedule for Plants Quick Answer: When optimizing for indoor plant lighting guide, it’s important to know that Light is the driving force behind photosynthesis. The right intensity and duration are essential to help your plants thrive indoors or in controlled environments. Our light converter helps you determine the correct light levels (lux → PPFD) and daily light hours depending on the crop type and its growth stage. By combining this with our , you can fine-tune your indoor garden lighting for maximum growth and yield. Optimal PPFD & DLI Ranges by Plant Stage Plant Type Growth Stage…

  • | |

    Coco Coir Hydroponics: Setup, EC, and pH Guide for Beginners

    Home > Hydroponics > Coco Coir Hydroponics: Setup, EC, and pH Guide for Beginners Last Reviewed: August 25, 2026  |  Author: Faisal Habib  |  Fact-Checked: Lab and Field Verified  |  Expert Reviewer: Wara Danish, MSc Plant Biology Difficulty: Beginner to Intermediate | Setup Time: 24–48 hours (double buffering) | Active Work: 45 minutes | Target pH: 5.8–6.2 | Target EC: 1.2–2.2 mS/cm | Runoff Target: 10%–25% ⚡ Quick Answer: Mastering Coco Coir Hydroponics Coco coir hydroponics is soilless growing in buffered coconut fiber. Success requires four numbers: buffer raw bricks in EC 1.4–1.6 mS/cm Cal-Mag for 12–24 hours, feed at pH 5.8–6.2 and EC 1.2–2.2 mS/cm, irrigate 1–5 times daily,…

  • | |

    How to Grow Hydroponic Tomatoes: Complete Setup Guide

    Home > Hydroponics > How to Grow Hydroponic Tomatoes: Complete Setup Guide Last Reviewed: August 26, 2026  |  Author: Faisal Habib  |  Fact-Checked: Lab and Field Verified  |  Expert Reviewer: Wara Danish, MSc Plant Biology Difficulty: Intermediate to Advanced | Target Crop: Indeterminate Tomatoes | Turnaround: 65–85 Days | Target EC: 2.0–3.5 mS/cm | pH: 5.8–6.2 ⚡ Quick Answer: How to Grow Hydroponic Tomatoes? To grow high-yielding hydroponic tomatoes, cultivate indeterminate varieties in perlite Dutch buckets under high-wire trellises, steering nutrient EC from 2.0 to 3.5 mS/cm and pH at 5.8–6.2 for 35–50 lbs of fruit per vine. 📊 Master Hydroponic Tomato Engineering & Agronomic Specs Recommended System: Dutch Bucket…

  • |

    Hydroponic Broccoli Varieties: Top 5 for Easy Growing

    Home > Hydroponics > Hydroponic Broccoli Varieties: Top 5 for Easy Growing Last Reviewed: August 2026  |  Author: Faisal Habib, CEA Systems Specialist  |  Fact-Checked: Lab and Field Verified  |  Expert Reviewer: Wara Danish, MSc Plant Biology Difficulty: Intermediate | Setup Time: 2–3 Hours | Estimated Cost: $75 to $200 | Days to Harvest: 55–80 ⚡ Quick Answer: Growing Hydroponic Broccoli Growing hydroponic broccoli requires EC 2.0–2.8 mS/cm, pH 6.0–6.8, and 3–4 weeks of vernalization at 45–55°F to form tight heads. The five best varieties are Blue Wind (55–60 days, fastest), Gypsy (heat-resistant), Bufga (heaviest DWC yields), Destiny (compact NFT), and Calabrese (prolific side shoots). Start seeds in rockwool at…

  • pH Pen vs pH Test Strips: Which Is More Accurate for Hydroponics?

    Home > Hydroponic Systems > pH Pen vs pH Test Strips: Which Is More Accurate for Hydroponics? Last Reviewed: August 2026  |  Author: Faisal Habib (Commercial Hydroponics Specialist)  |  Fact-Checked: Analytical Laboratory Verified  |  Expert Reviewer: Wara Danish, MSc Plant Biology Difficulty: Beginner to Advanced | Testing Time: 2–5 Minutes | Hardware Cost: $8 – $160 | Target Accuracy: ±0.01 to ±0.5 pH ⚡ Quick Answer: pH Pen vs Test Strips Evaluating a pH pen vs test strips reveals three distinct accuracy tiers: digital pH pens deliver laboratory precision (±0.01 to ±0.05 pH) with Automatic Temperature Compensation, making them essential for recirculating commercial systems. Liquid drop kits offer reliable intermediate…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *